Origins

In The UFO Experience (1972), J. Allen Hynek distinguished a report's strangeness from its credibility. His Strangeness Rating concerned the number of details difficult to explain; his separate Probability Rating concerned whether the event occurred as reported. Hynek (1972), Chapter Four.

This supports linking the concept to Hynek's work. It does not establish that he was the first person to use the exact phrase.

John Keel's investigations brought UFO reports together with monster sightings, strange communications and coincidences. His surviving drafts show how he developed the material later used in The Mothman Prophecies (1975). Keel's original Mothman drafts.

Core Traits

The following are reported motifs, not established effects of a single phenomenon.

  • Time anomalies witnesses lose hours or find that clocks stop at the moment of the encounter. Missing time is a hallmark of high-strangeness reports.
  • Poltergeist effects knocks, raps or objects moving without explanation often accompany the sighting.
  • Telepathic impressions witnesses sometimes report thoughts or messages that do not seem their own.
  • Absurd encounters figures such as Men in Black act robotic or deliver nonsensical warnings, and other beings behave in ways that confuse more than inform.
  • Trickster elements events often feel staged, as if designed to puzzle rather than convey a clear message.

Folklore Parallels

Jacques Vallée's Passport to Magonia (1969) compared UFO narratives with older stories of aerial visitors and fairy encounters. Similarities between stories can be studied without assuming that the beings in them exist or share one origin. Vallée's bibliography and book description.

Case Studies

Point Pleasant and Skinwalker Ranch illustrate the difference between a recorded claim and an independently documented event.

  • Mothman, Point Pleasant (1966-1967). Keel collected accounts of a winged figure, UFOs and unusual communications. His archive preserves the investigation's raw material; it does not independently confirm a paranormal connection between the reports.
  • Silver Bridge, 15 December 1967. The bridge collapse is independently documented. NIST preserves the failed eyebar that initiated the collapse. That physical evidence does not substantiate claims that Mothman caused or predicted the disaster. NIST Silver Bridge archive.
  • Skinwalker Ranch. Colm Kelleher and George Knapp's Hunt for the Skinwalker (2005) describes reports of unusual lights, creatures and cattle incidents at the Utah property. It is an account by participants in the investigation; publication does not independently validate a shared paranormal cause. Hunt for the Skinwalker.

Hypotheses In Play

These interpretations make different claims. None follows automatically from calling an encounter strange.

  • Ultraterrestrials Keel proposed hidden intelligences behind apparently unrelated encounters. This is his interpretation, not an established population of beings.
  • Interdimensional bleed-through some theorists argue that phenomena cross from another plane into ours, which could account for time distortions and seemingly impossible effects.
  • Psychosocial hypothesis this view proposes that at least some UFO reports are best explained by psychological or social factors. It treats UFOs as a worthy subject of study but emphasises cultural and perceptual influences.
  • Extraterrestrial craft The proposal that visitors from other worlds cause the events requires evidence beyond unexplained observations.

FAQs

  • What did John Keel mean by “high strangeness”? His writing brought UFO accounts together with strange communications, monster reports and apparent coincidences. His interpretations should be distinguished from the underlying witness accounts.
  • Is high strangeness the same as the paranormal? Not exactly. Paranormal covers ghosts, hauntings and cryptids; high strangeness refers specifically to UFO-linked anomalies that mix physical sightings with other bizarre phenomena.
  • What are examples of high-strangeness cases? Mothman sightings, Skinwalker Ranch events and abduction stories marked by missing time all fall under the high-strangeness label.

Explore Further

To learn more, see these related pages:

Join The Conversation

The debate over high strangeness is ongoing. New reports continue to emerge, and researchers across disciplines are still trying to make sense of them. If you want to discuss these cases as they unfold and share theories or sources, join our Discord to connect with other enthusiasts.